moral permissibility of drugs

Started by trent bortknob, March 3, 2010 04:30 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

trent bortknob

ok so this is a serious debate topic

i think it's important because it actually applies to most people in our age group and i have no idea what the correct answer is

Is it ever good to use drugs? If not, is it at least morally permissible to do so? (basically is it just "ok")

if you're cool please post your arguments/beliefs and back them up

if you're gay then please try to be as hilarious as possible

MarcK

Unexpectedly hilarious post by marck.

Mew_User


DrRumack

Quote from: MarcKUnexpectedly hilarious post by marck.
nope still gay

also what do you mean by 'good'

i mean its certainly not productive or healthy for most people, although ive heard of some weirdos that smoke weed and become super focused on whatever they are doing

its morally permissible in my opinion but it hasnt done much good for most people i know

<Naza> i hate penis exect mine
<Tyler Naugle> JOKE  TIME w/ JOKEOB BRECK
<+pantsman> you have yet to show me any applicable sign of intelligence yet scrib...
<HatsuneMiku> the pings and timeouts of jacob breck
<dilly> the tba will look up and cry "save us!".... and i'll look down and whisper .... "h"
Quote from: stealth trollwhat's up with you not sucking dicks like the faggot you are
<+fluffkomix> mrscriblam has added you as a friend
<+fluffkomix> ignore

<+mrscriblam> lmao

rtil

i believe people have the right to do whatever they want to their bodies, and no one has the right to tell them otherwise as long as they are not harming others. whether it's harmful or good is determined by if it consumes their life to the point where they become dependent on it or it makes them dysfunctional. obviously some substances are far more dangerous and apt to do that to someone. our government has a double standard legalizing hard liquor and toxic cigarettes while posession of marijuana a potentially serious criminal charge. the bottom line is the government has no business telling us what we can and can't consume because we're going to do it anyway

trent bortknob

Quote from: BamyasiDefine drug.
um i guess i should have done this

in this case it\\\'s a substance with mind altering effects taken for that reason

Quote from: MrScriblam
Quote from: MarcKUnexpectedly hilarious post by marck.
nope still gay

also what do you mean by \\\'good\\\'

i mean its certainly not productive or healthy for most people, although ive heard of some weirdos that smoke weed and become super focused on whatever they are doing

its morally permissible in my opinion but it hasnt done much good for most people i know
yeah when i say good that\\\'s what i mean; is it ever beneficial to ALL people (i kind of believe the kantian idea that, in regards to morality, there is no decision that\\\'s good for one person and not good for another. so in that case, if it were good for one person to smoke weed it would be good for all people, and thats what this debate is about)

also rtil i understand your argument but in this case im not speaking of legality because the legality of something doesn\\\'t necessarily entail its moral permissibility but you do bring up a good point

Daveb0t

I can shove an entire hand in my asshole!

billy

drug use is worse than rape

because it\\\'s like a rape of your own body

anigen

drugs are generally bad but the world's too broken to be freed of them so honestly all i can say is do what ya like

personally i only really mess with the green medicine but it's not really often enough for me to be a pothead

rtil

Quote from: Billydrug use is worse than rape

because it's like a rape of your own body
how is harming yourself on purpose worse than harming someone else who doesn't deserve to be harmed

as far as 'moral permissibility' goes, morals come from society, and drugs have been around since the beginning of mankind. so religion aside they're acceptable

billy

Quote from: rtil
Quote from: Billydrug use is worse than rape

because it's like a rape of your own body
how is harming yourself on purpose worse than harming someone else who doesn't deserve to be harmed

as far as 'moral permissibility' goes, morals come from society, and drugs have been around since the beginning of mankind. so religion aside they're acceptable
trolld

shura

#11
i have a friend in princeton who says that everyone there does cocaine and amphetamines to keep up with the academics. in my highschool ecstasy and prescription pills were really popular. drugs are definitely socially acceptable depending on where you are and who you hang out with. as far as morally permissible, i see nothing wrong with doing drugs as long as you use them responsibly and you're aware of what you're doing to yourself

emanhattan

I think appart from the fact that whoever consumes them can probably harm his body too much without realizing it ,the other half of the problem with drugs is when they affect people other than the consumer (family,friends,etc).

Ive never had any problems of this sort because I simply dont like doing them. I do drink a lot and smoke but i wouldnt do more pot, etc ever again.
shits just bad man

rtil

Quote from: Billy
Quote from: rtil
Quote from: Billydrug use is worse than rape

because it's like a rape of your own body
how is harming yourself on purpose worse than harming someone else who doesn't deserve to be harmed

as far as 'moral permissibility' goes, morals come from society, and drugs have been around since the beginning of mankind. so religion aside they're acceptable
trolld

emanhattan


dilly

Quote from: tospocahontas was shit
no she was native american dumbass

god

<@reptilicus> am I in backwards land?
<@reptilicus> if i go to the toilet will poop go up into my rectum

rtil

Quote from: tospocahontas was shit
sounds like somebody can't paint with all the colors of the wind

Kött

The keywords are heavy physical and psycological damage.

One pro point for making these drugs illegal is that you would as well get locked away if you got caught harming yourself, only that it's called psychatry. The modern law, as modern as it is, is it still based on religious commandments in its roots which were the first and (as abstractly as it may seem nowadays after humanity has witnessed so many crimes and genocides based on religion) an indispensable step into the direction of socialization and one of the Ten Commandments is "Thou shalt not kill" after all, as well applying to suicide or self mutilation and consuming drugs clearly is a kind of self mutilation, regarding the above mentioned keywords any drug can cause.
The ethical question why a man shouldn't be able to decide what's best for himself, even if  it is suicide or self mutilation for what reason ever can't be answered with that agrument and I am not a religious person at all but I think that I would do anything to prevent someone from killing or hurting himself and that it's just the right thing you should do for anyone, especially because man can suffer from extreme erratic mood swings as well as being mind controlled by lots of exogenous factors. There are so many people who have tried to kill themselves, failed and live a happy life today.

Drugs definitely are taking influence on people's behaviour and their mood. People could do things they would never do if they were clean which leads to the my second point against drugs:
It is commonly known how far addictions can go... You hear stories about people, sucking dicks for crack and this example is only a well known one because it sounds pathetic and ridiculous. How many more people do you think steal, rob and kill to be able to satisfy their addiction, not clearly realizing how far they are going for it because of the effects of the drug they are addicted to and that is something harmful that involves other people and can't be justified by any ethical thought.
It may be an extreme and rare example but illegal drugs are banned for a reason and as you hopefully don't have any experience with the really hard drugs such as heroine or cocaine, to which your harmless pot may only be the gateway drug, you shouldn't magnify drugs in general; don't connec them with your innocent storybook Rastafarian, making Raggae music about world peace and unicorns while smoking weed. A drug is a drug and the way it alters and influences people can be dangerous.

At the other hand alcohol is a drug as well and scientifically seen it's even less healthy, more dangerous and has a much bigger addiction quote than the illegal drug marihuana. So, how comes that booze is legal but weed isn't? The answer probably is that alcohol is and has always been the most established drug. It's easy to produce, has been consumed in every known ancient culture and there are so many ways to create it that the natural goods it requires can be found on any place of the world and of course be bought at any grocery. Banning alcohol would lead to nothing but that anyone would produce his own vines and hard liquors and would heavily damage the economy.
It may be the drug that has taken most lives, that has caused most violent acts and that has driven more people insane than any other drug has and ever will but it has always been legal and has reached a too high status to ever be made illegal by any modern government.
Well, in Saudi Arabia you actually can be executed for consuming alcohol... but that's an exception I think...
Anyway, my main pro argument for alcohol is that it can create a lot of joy and happyness, brings people together and frees them from their social fears. I can't imagine a really great party without at least some beer... sad but true and still most people would agree.

I for myself prefer boozing over everything else and I don't think that's gonna change... and as a rule of thumb not to be overpowered by the negative aspects of alcohol, but possibly pretty much applyable for anything (as well as for you potsmokers out there) I can only end this post with the following German saw:

The dose defines the poison.
:3

zhicago

im going to try and make sense of my own opinions here uhh here we go

when i was growing up (4-12 years old), my stepdad was really hardcore into drugs. he would come off them, and get back on them, over and over. he used to speedball (cocaine and heroin) in front of me. some of my worst memories are sitting in the backseat at 1 am while he made my mom drive through the nastiest parts of baltimore trying to hook up with some dealers. its not as simple as you think when youre in a car because you cant just roll up to the guy and have him give it to you. generally you have to pick him up and then take him somewhere more secluded that he can give it to you. the dealer has to be publically available when hes trying to get customers, but private when he actually makes the transaction. so with that being said, i had to sit next to drug dealers in the backseat half the time. i would have to watch them snort/shoot shit up because most of the time they used too. ew

that being said, the worst times of my life were when my stepdad was using. we would have to steal (yes i learned how to steal very well at a young age), live in motels, and watch him treat my mom like shit. and the problem is that he wasnt even really a bad guy-- but when he didnt have his fix, nothing else really mattered to him. he HAD to have it and he would do anything to get it. it was the addiction that was bad. its hard to stop an addiction when youve been using drugs since you were 17.
he died when i was 13 on an overdose of cocaine.

i think what im trying to say is, i always had a really terrible (and phobic, even) view on drugs, but this past year or so, i have really relaxed on it to the point that i believe drugs could be okay if the addiction part wasn't such a horrific awful thing to witness.
i think this country is really backwards with its drug laws too. i think weed should not be outlawed because it really doesn't have addictive properties, and the people who appear to be 'addicted' to it are only that way because they've come to rely on its more sedative properties.

a lot of the time, people who use drugs are doing it as an escape from the boring, the stressful, and the more asinine aspects of their life. there are a lot of different (and better) ways for you to escape your problems however so this shouldnt really be an excuse to take them. i think that people need to be reminded that all a drug is a cocktail of chemicals that rearrange the way your brain is working, and not some kind of door to an alternate plane of existence. and when you are using drugs for your own personal benefit you need to think about the other people in your life who are going to be affected by your usage. they almost always become #2 in your life when you are using drugs, because nobody. NOBODY. can give you the rush that a shot of heroin or a hit of meth can give you.

have fun stay safe check your references at http://erowid.org/ before you do anything, and please always consider your family and friends. they will always be there for you, even when youre coming down

sevv: btw dude you dropped your wacky-colored paste-on nose here i'll give it back to you

rtil

Quote from: zhicagoim going to try and make sense of my own opinions here uhh here we go

when i was growing up (4-12 years old), my stepdad was really hardcore into drugs. he would come off them, and get back on them, over and over. he used to speedball (cocaine and heroin) in front of me. some of my worst memories are sitting in the backseat at 1 am while he made my mom drive through the nastiest parts of baltimore trying to hook up with some dealers. its not as simple as you think when youre in a car because you cant just roll up to the guy and have him give it to you. generally you have to pick him up and then take him somewhere more secluded that he can give it to you. the dealer has to be publically available when hes trying to get customers, but private when he actually makes the transaction. so with that being said, i had to sit next to drug dealers in the backseat half the time. i would have to watch them snort/shoot shit up because most of the time they used too. ew

that being said, the worst times of my life were when my stepdad was using. we would have to steal (yes i learned how to steal very well at a young age), live in motels, and watch him treat my mom like shit. and the problem is that he wasnt even really a bad guy-- but when he didnt have his fix, nothing else really mattered to him. he HAD to have it and he would do anything to get it. it was the addiction that was bad. its hard to stop an addiction when youve been using drugs since you were 17.
he died when i was 13 on an overdose of cocaine.

i think what im trying to say is, i always had a really terrible (and phobic, even) view on drugs, but this past year or so, i have really relaxed on it to the point that i believe drugs could be okay if the addiction part wasn\\\'t such a horrific awful thing to witness.
i think this country is really backwards with its drug laws too. i think weed should not be outlawed because it really doesn\\\'t have addictive properties, and the people who appear to be \\\'addicted\\\' to it are only that way because they\\\'ve come to rely on its more sedative properties.
that, and cigarettes have addictive and harmful ingredients and you can buy them anywhere.

because of reagan\\\'s "war on drugs" you had to endure that as a child. if drugs were regulated,  he could have bought them at the store and not been a criminal and dealing with criminals.

government banning creates a black market and turns often regular people into outlaws. not saying that some of the more hard drugs already turn you into something horrible, but a bag of pot can land you in prison with murderers and rapists.

by regulating and taxing these drugs, you put the gangs and dealers out of business, and make it easier for drug addicts to get help, because they won\\\'t be making friends with dangerous criminals for their fix and constantly putting theirs and their families\\\' lives in danger because of it.

it\\\'s simply the best way to combat drugs, because trying to make them go away hasn\\\'t worked for thousands of years.