due to popular demand

Started by rtil, January 27, 2009 02:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hammi

#20
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Score: 2
Blockhead: Quick Shot 2

"meh"
submission: Blockhead: Quick Shot 2
date: July 6, 2008


ok..i better be careful how i word this or it's just going to get deleted for not being a 10/10.

first of all, the animation was really confusing. characters' heads were flailing around for no reason and a lot of the mouth shapes didn't match up with what they were saying. it is possible to do a lot of overacting in animation and i think this is an example of that. it's smooth, but it's really frantic for no reason and that makes it suffer.

secondly i have just found this series to be predictable for a really long time. the only thing funny was when i correctly assumed you would make a "tongs" reference, which is a long-time cheeseball staple of your series that i don't even get what is funny about. i mean, i *do* get the concept - blockhead is completely detached from the world and treats everything in a manner we wouldn't by nature. it's like yotsuba, except with bad writing, ADD and a throwaway character design.

i dunno what else to say. because honestly this is probably better than a bunch of dick jokes set to black and red. i don't have any advice except for studying acting for animation. this kind of writing is obviously your style, but i just feel like everyone else is already doing it, so to me it is pretty boring and stale.

that doesn't make me the authority on these things, they are merely my opinions. try and keep that in mind for your own sake.

July 7, 2008
Author's Response:

Actually, you missed the tongs joke completely. My character was rolling his eyes at the tongs references because he, i.e. I, was/is tired of the running gag. If the whole tongs thing weren't predictable, then the joke about my character being irked at the reference wouldn't have worked. Despite your best efforts, I tricked you into agreeing with me.

Also, I thought you said in your MM3 review that Mastermind was better than Blockhead ever could be. Did you change your mind or something? Maybe I'll make a new series so that you can hate them both at the same time <3

Also, to my fellow mods, please do not delete this review xoxo. Although he's not offering any advice on how to improve, rtil is at least giving his thought-out opinion.


There's some debate, but overall people find this review helpful


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

i really cant find any other reviews close to april month, concerning swain. Unless this is what youre talking about:

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"hmm."
submission: Blockhead: Episode 8
date: November 2, 2006


animation is getting better, i like that. the motion is down i think the timing is still off in some cases. i never understood why all the characters except for blockhead are so incredibly stiff and can't express themselves near as well as blockhead can. as far as supporting cast goes it's rather weak. Just the same old 3-second-memoryspan in his own world blockhead, nothing really new. One part made me laugh though, when he roared at the people in that house. Hooray.

People think this is a useless review.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
<GreatRapperLenkazuka> lmao
<GreatRapperLenkazuka> hammi you are my top paki
<GreatPakiHammizuka> top at dem all maynn


shura

lmao. so what can Swain "do what you can't and with half the effort"??

zomfgbie

i don't understand why they get so pissy

they get 6830459 reviews treating them like theyre the second coming of jesus then they get 1 review poiting out the flaws and they start throwing their toys out of the crib

harsh reviews need to be left to neutralise the dicksucking that goes on and to say what fanboys are afraid to
i am dead

<+wwchicken> once i walked into the kitchen and there was a sound
<+wwchicken> but i could only hear it when i stood on one spot in the kitchen
<+wwchicken> then i turned off the light
<+wwchicken> and it was gone
<+wwchicken> then i turned the light back on and there it was again
<+wwchicken> so i thought, its an invisible alien
<+wwchicken> but hes scared of the dark

Daveb0t

Quote from: FreekCi don't understand why they get so pissy

they get 6830459 reviews treating them like theyre the second coming of jesus then they get 1 review poiting out the flaws and they start throwing their toys out of the crib

harsh reviews need to be left to neutralise the dicksucking that goes on and to say what fanboys are afraid to
Truely this

Gmagnum

#24
this post has been removed
i'm really sorry about all my stupidity on this forum.
i didn't know what i was talking about and was an asshole.
so i take back all of this as it no longer represents me.
i was unable to remove the posts in the locked threads.

lenko

Meh i like the swain he's a cool dude, but he should have known he would just be supplying rtil with more laughs with a response like that . I don't get the 'inbetween animator' diss, that's where a lot of famous animators started off (or at least worked at one point or another) before getting higher up and becoming directors or pitching their own show.

utah seems to respond the worst to neg. criticism by far, whether it's about his flashes or about NG. Or street fighter. dude blows his lid if you diss street fighter.
<emanhattan> i remember pingu ice cream
<emanhattan> it was a better time
<emanhattan> when the penguins were cold and delicious
<emanhattan> and i knew i was gonna be
<emanhattan> consequence free

Greenkitten

Quote from: lenkabiscai like the swain he's a cool dude
he seems like a nice fellow



Daveb0t

Quote from: lenkabiscautah seems to respond the worst to neg. criticism by far, whether it's about his flashes or about NG. Or street fighter. dude blows his lid if you diss street fighter.
I like when  I posted something RVS said to me and he started going off on an unrelated tangent about how he goes to film festivals and he knows what the people of NG will like.

DrRumack

Quote from: Billymost of tba is up for a tank award, is swainy boy up for a tank award?

leet pwnage
actually i think mastermind 2 or 3 or whatever is up for one


of course that doesnt make him less of a huge faggot for getting all pissy like that

<Naza> i hate penis exect mine
<Tyler Naugle> JOKE  TIME w/ JOKEOB BRECK
<+pantsman> you have yet to show me any applicable sign of intelligence yet scrib...
<HatsuneMiku> the pings and timeouts of jacob breck
<dilly> the tba will look up and cry "save us!".... and i'll look down and whisper .... "h"
Quote from: stealth trollwhat's up with you not sucking dicks like the faggot you are
<+fluffkomix> mrscriblam has added you as a friend
<+fluffkomix> ignore

<+mrscriblam> lmao

Daveb0t


8 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
7 Members: Jeinu, MishkaMash, MrScriblam, Ying, Kirbopher, mr. sweaty ass, lenkabisca

 

lenko

Oh and i think the actual review was for mastermind 3. I remember it disappearing

It was something along the lines of dissing the guest voices i dunno

I think swain is just upset that rtil doesnt like his stuff because he likes his animations or something i dunno. And like most NG animators swain went through the 'formula':

"He doesn't like my animation. Therefore, he doesn't like me!"

As for utah, i can kind of imagine him typing angry responses 'ironically' and him and tom fulp laughing behind the computer. But he does seem pretty angry!!!!
<emanhattan> i remember pingu ice cream
<emanhattan> it was a better time
<emanhattan> when the penguins were cold and delicious
<emanhattan> and i knew i was gonna be
<emanhattan> consequence free

zomfgbie

oh right that metal gear funnies thing you guys did

my part was half-finished when i got called for active duty  but you guys did an awesome job
i am dead

<+wwchicken> once i walked into the kitchen and there was a sound
<+wwchicken> but i could only hear it when i stood on one spot in the kitchen
<+wwchicken> then i turned off the light
<+wwchicken> and it was gone
<+wwchicken> then i turned the light back on and there it was again
<+wwchicken> so i thought, its an invisible alien
<+wwchicken> but hes scared of the dark

rtil

Quote from: GrndClockdamn i thought you were gonna de-admin psi
he is de-adminned

Quote from: lenkabiscaI don\\\'t get the \\\'inbetween animator\\\' diss
he thinks because i\\\'m not gettin friendly with all the ng higher-ups and the staff that i won\\\'t go anywhere

cuz yknow all great animators have their roots in newgrounds

zomfgbie

Quote from: lenkabiscaI don't get the 'inbetween animator' diss
he thinks because i'm not gettin friendly with all the ng higher-ups and the staff that i won't go anywhere

cuz yknow all great animators have their roots in newgrounds

here lies a joke about tex avery being an admin of oldgrounds
i am dead

<+wwchicken> once i walked into the kitchen and there was a sound
<+wwchicken> but i could only hear it when i stood on one spot in the kitchen
<+wwchicken> then i turned off the light
<+wwchicken> and it was gone
<+wwchicken> then i turned the light back on and there it was again
<+wwchicken> so i thought, its an invisible alien
<+wwchicken> but hes scared of the dark

Fuzz

Maye if you left him a bad review under a different name? Maybe he just doesn't like YOU. Eh?

rtil

he doesn't like me lmao

and the review in question has long since been deleted

i'm not interested in leaving helpful critique on newgrounds anymore, much less his work. i gave him a 10/10 on his last blockhead cartoon with a review saying something like "lol tongs!" and i didn't watch it

"fuck it! we'll do it live"
-bill 'o reilly

Daveb0t

I think its fun giving helpful critiques but in the most nasty way possible.  Or to act kindly but point out every conceivable flaw

rtil

i think it's fun to jesus christ what the fuck is that

mishkamash

that obviously looks like an impression of a vagina that little cocksucker
<lenko> i saw a hedgehog on the way home if i was drunk i would have yelled IM DOCTOR RRRRROBOTNIK and chased it 

Gmagnum

#39
this post has been removed
i'm really sorry about all my stupidity on this forum.
i didn't know what i was talking about and was an asshole.
so i take back all of this as it no longer represents me.
i was unable to remove the posts in the locked threads.

|