Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs

[ansel]

i feel no need to respond because i still think it's a gay movie and you haven't changed my opinion at all

[jjjjjjjjjj]

[18:52] <~rtil> it's a delayed pwn
[18:53] <~rtil> you'll wake up in th emiddle of the night
[18:53] <~rtil> and go
[18:53] <~rtil> wow
[18:53] <~rtil> jseed totally pwned me earlier
[18:53] <~rtil> !

[funzop]

it looks like shit and im not going to watch it
and do you know what ill be missing in my life

a forgettable kids film about cheese falling from the sky

also jseed the changes you mention are small
watchmen had COOL OPENING CREDITS WOW THEY DIDNT HAVE COOL OPENING CREDITS IN THE BOOK!!! and in charlie and the chocolate factory they edited a whole 10 pages of the book big whup

this movie just takes the concept of food falling from the sky and makes a completly different plot out of it

[funzop]

its like writing a tribute album for a band
you can do crazy things with your tribute song like add a line or play it in a different genre of music

but youre not going to rewrite a song about the same thing the original was about and call it a "tribute"

[Necronomitr0n]

[jjjjjjjjjj]

it looks like shit and im not going to watch it
and do you know what ill be missing in my life

a forgettable kids film about cheese falling from the sky

im not forcing you to watch the movie nor can you say it sucks
even rtil with his opinion with 9 thinks that it looks lame but he doesnt hate it

also jseed the changes you mention are small
watchmen had COOL OPENING CREDITS WOW THEY DIDNT HAVE COOL OPENING CREDITS IN THE BOOK!!! and in charlie and the chocolate factory they edited a whole 10 pages of the book big whup

this movie just takes the concept of food falling from the sky and makes a completly different plot out of it

the opening credits were not in the book no what I meant to say was the things that they added INTO the opening credits
like the deaths of the superheros or the silk spectre's retirement
ok ill give you another great example
John carpenters "The Thing"
Stayed only a bit true to the plot but became a completly different story and made the monster different from what it orignally was
and it was better than the original
james and the giant peach changed ALOT of things
Stardust as well

its like writing a tribute album for a band
you can do crazy things with your tribute song like add a line or play it in a different genre of music

but youre not going to rewrite a song about the same thing the original was about and call it a "tribute"

a tribute is not an adaptation

[jjjjjjjjjj]

alone as a story it wouldnt have worked as a movie on its own at all of course there was going to be a change in plot

[CoolDrMoney]

Do the kids eat all the meatballs and become very fat? : )

[Happy]

I think I'll go sneak into it on a week day. If I end up liking it, I'll buy a ticket for it. If I dislike it then I'll probably leave early/

[funzop]

im not forcing you to watch the movie nor can you say it sucks
even rtil with his opinion with 9 thinks that it looks lame but he doesnt hate it

you cannot force me to watch it but i am allowed to be ignorant and stubborn ok this is what i choose to be

the opening credits were not in the book no what I meant to say was the things that they added INTO the opening credits
like the deaths of the superheros or the silk spectre's retirement
ok ill give you another great example
John carpenters "The Thing"
Stayed only a bit true to the plot but became a completly different story and made the monster different from what it orignally was
and it was better than the original
james and the giant peach changed ALOT of things
Stardust as well

im pretty sure the retirement of silk spectre and the deaths of the heros were implied in the original book
i dunno i might be crazy but isnt there a part where rorschach talks about what happened to all the old heros
i never saw the thing so i wouldnt know
james and the giant peach kept a lot of it the same as well though

if youve ever read the original you would know
1. its a shitty book
2. theres no real main character its just "once upon a time food fell from the sky then it stopped the end"

a tribute is not an adaptation

ok then say i was adapting a book about a boy and girl falling in love after meeting in a magic green field with an evil witch trying to keep them apart
i wouldnt make the movie set on mars and make the witch shoot lasers from her electric guitar and ice cream fly out her eyes

[jjjjjjjjjj]

im not forcing you to watch the movie nor can you say it sucks
even rtil with his opinion with 9 thinks that it looks lame but he doesnt hate it

you cannot force me to watch it but i am allowed to be ignorant and stubborn ok this is what i choose to be

ok?

the opening credits were not in the book no what I meant to say was the things that they added INTO the opening credits
like the deaths of the superheros or the silk spectre's retirement
ok ill give you another great example
John carpenters "The Thing"
Stayed only a bit true to the plot but became a completly different story and made the monster different from what it orignally was
and it was better than the original
james and the giant peach changed ALOT of things
Stardust as well

you dont actually see it in the comics though it was referenced it wasnt actually seen or shown
im pretty sure the retirement of silk spectre and the deaths of the heros were implied in the original book
i dunno i might be crazy but isnt there a part where rorschach talks about what happened to all the old heros
i never saw the thing so i wouldnt know
james and the giant peach kept a lot of it the same as well though

it was never shown in the comic it was just referenced and the parody of the soldier kissing the nurse during the world war was not in the comic too
even if watchmen isn't a good choice you cannot deny about the othe ideas

if youve ever read the original you would know
1. its a shitty book
2. theres no real main character its just "once upon a time food fell from the sky then it stopped the end"

no fucking shit?
thats why i posted

alone as a story it wouldnt have worked as a movie on its own at all of course there was going to be a change in plot

isn't this for the better anyways if the book was so shitty?

a tribute is not an adaptation

ok then say i was adapting a book about a boy and girl falling in love after meeting in a magic green field with an evil witch trying to keep them apart
i wouldnt make the movie set on mars and make the witch shoot lasers from her electric guitar and ice cream fly out her eyes

yes but if the orignal was so shitty wouldn't this be for the better anyhow
especially since it was written by a show that became a cult hit in the us

either way knowing you youll probably pull something gay  saying you were 'trolling' or whatever
logical fallacy on a movie with a completely different plot  to something you havent seen
HEY GUYS MOVIE X SUCKS IHAVENT SEEN IT HURP

[jjjjjjjjjj]

hey heres another book adaptation that changed the plot entirely and became a great fucking movie

[emanhattan]

The trailer/posters made me think "wow this looks teh shitty" but Ill probably give it a go

[retrosmash]

MOVIE ARGUMENTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[rtil]

10 years from now they'll do a 3d adaptation of streganona and we will have this same argument

[funzop]

ok?

alright!!

it was never shown in the comic it was just referenced and the parody of the soldier kissing the nurse during the world war was not in the comic too
even if watchmen isn't a good choice you cannot deny about the othe ideas

i forgot about dat part o yeh
i havent seen most of the other ideas so i couldnt tell you!!

no fucking shit?
thats why i posted

alone as a story it wouldnt have worked as a movie on its own at all of course there was going to be a change in plot

isn't this for the better anyways if the book was so shitty?

i think it shouldnt have been made a movie in da first place but maybe thats just me!!

yes but if the orignal was so shitty wouldn't this be for the better anyhow
especially since it was written by a show that became a cult hit in the us

either way knowing you youll probably pull something gay  saying you were 'trolling' or whatever
logical fallacy on a movie with a completely different plot  to something you havent seen
HEY GUYS MOVIE X SUCKS IHAVENT SEEN IT HURP

just because im disagreeing doesnt mean im trolling or that im trying to be an asshole
i wasnt serious if you hadnt guessed but i wasnt trying to work you up and troll you or anything like that
i know its stupid to judge a movie before i see it ok im not that thick

[DrRumack]

well i liked the lil bits ive seen from clone high so maybe ill like this too

[ansel]

if they had to make such drastic changes to the plot maybe it's a sign they shouldn't have made the movie in the first place

[jjjjjjjjjj]

if they had to make such drastic changes to the plot maybe it's a sign they shouldn't have made the movie in the first place

hey heres another book adaptation that changed the plot entirely and became a great fucking movie

also lmao DRASTIC CHANGES to like
a 10 lined kids book

[psi43]

in case someone finds a working torrent or stream which is not a virus i'd be interested thanks