Cintiq 21UX

Started by ansel, March 11, 2009 10:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mishkamash

aka fingerless sleeved gloves
<lenko> i saw a hedgehog on the way home if i was drunk i would have yelled IM DOCTOR RRRRROBOTNIK and chased it 

Daveb0t

Just getting used to not being able to rotate my intuos was a big step, a good one when adjusting to sketching on larger areas, but I could never stand drawing in the same positions as I paint.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YEt1BuYaoZo

rtil

#22
Quote from: ansel
Quote from: chickeni was thinking about buying the smaller version of that, but doesnt the screen get all muffy cos youre hands are all over it all the time?
doesnt that get irritating while drawing?

I've never used the smaller one, but to me a 12" screen just seems really small in terms of drawing space. rtil has the 12" one though, maybe he can shed some light on this issue. I assume the screen will probably get dirty if I use it often, but I can probable just clean it off from time to time, or wear a silly little thing made for this exact reason, which is a thin glove that covers only the bottom side of your hand, leaving your pointer/index fingers free.

i dunno how many times i've said this but in my opinion the 12WX is not worth it. the screen being dirty is the smallest of issues when you consider the severe design flaws in the 12WX. the only advantage it poses would be that you're drawing directly on surface, which to me isn't much of an advantage in the first place - the reason i like the intuos is because your hand is not in the way of the drawing surface. with the cintiq your hand is directly in front of a bright screen blocking some of your view of the canvas, just like on paper. and now that a lot of painting applications offer canvas rotation (photoshop and painter being two popular examples), the rotation aspect of the 21UX is beginning to lose its appeal.

but anyway, back to the 12WX. here's some things to consider:
  • no rotation - period. there is a mount on the back but it is for wall units (?)
  • crappy stand that doesn't stay up. it's hard to find a comfortable position to use this thing
  • fucking fat cord on the top that connects to a giant converter box (aka this thing is not portable - i don't know why wacom advertises that)
  • within 1 inch of the edges of the screen the calibration goes off and the line you draw suddenly jitters, thus making a 1" dimension around the screen pretty much unusable and unreliable. this has never been addressed or fixed.
  • horrible resolution and crap factory colors. in fact even with expert calibration it still has horrible gamma. you won't see the full color spectrum on this thing. pixel pitch sucks and the max res is 1280x800.
if i were you, i would save up money for the 21UX if you really want a cintiq. i wouldn't complain if i had a 21UX but honestly i am pretty content with my 6x8 intuos 3 and i use it way more often than my 12WX which quite frankly serves better as a 2nd monitor.

GRINACE

is it really worth having the 6x8 intuos? I mean i have the 4x6 and its serves me well.

rtil

the larger your intuos is the more accurate your marks will be. remember that the wacom software has to guesstimate the place you're putting down your pen to the position on the screen

shura

so the smaller the wacom, the less accurate it is?? i have a small-sized bamboo fun tablet and the lines sometimes come out really jittery making me have to redraw the line over again. i thought maybe it was me. but is it the tablet?

lenko

the smaller the tablet, the shittier it is
<emanhattan> i remember pingu ice cream
<emanhattan> it was a better time
<emanhattan> when the penguins were cold and delicious
<emanhattan> and i knew i was gonna be
<emanhattan> consequence free

GRINACE

lol that has to suck on my laptops screen. Btw is it bad to get a different brand of tablet? Cause i payed 200 for the 4x6 intous but i was looking around tigerdirect (where i got my laptop) and i saw a genius tablet 8x6 for only 50 bucks.

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/Se...9&CatId=140

is wacom that great that i have to pay 150 bucks more for a brand name, smaler tablet.

ansel

Quote from: Sashuraso the smaller the wacom, the less accurate it is?? i have a small-sized bamboo fun tablet and the lines sometimes come out really jittery making me have to redraw the line over again. i thought maybe it was me. but is it the tablet?

Well when you draw a line on a tablet smaller than your screen, it has to enlarge your pen movements to fit the screen resolution, resulting in a loss of line quality and jitteriness. It's partly that you're not looking where you're drawing -- it'd take a LOT of practice to perfect your hand-eye coordination--but it's also that the tablet is the "wrong" size and that it's less sensitive than a larger one. I spent a LOT of time ctrl-zing and redrawing the same line again and again to get it perfect, and i foresee a lot less of that now

Quote from: Factoryshut up you skinny white ugly prick

rtil

Quote from: GRINACElol that has to suck on my laptops screen. Btw is it bad to get a different brand of tablet? Cause i payed 200 for the 4x6 intous but i was looking around tigerdirect (where i got my laptop) and i saw a genius tablet 8x6 for only 50 bucks.

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/Se...9&CatId=140

is wacom that great that i have to pay 150 bucks more for a brand name, smaler tablet.
good question. you should read reviews first. i've never used any brand besides wacom

shittyfurryass

Quote from: rtilsee folks this is why if you want a cintiq you should just save up for the 21ux it makes the 12wx look more like a piece of crap than it already is

This post came a month too late

I bought myself a 12wx for my birthday and boy am I disappointed.  My EEE pc that cost me $180 new has a better looking display, and my cellphone calibrates better than it.  Why does my phone test calibration at 5 points while my cintiq tests at only two?! This makes working with a god awfully low resolution even more annoying when you cant make the most out of the edges of the screen. I am hoping a driver update will fix this.  Not to mention the tablet is small, but shares the same trade offs as having a big one in terms of portability since the thing is a frigging octopus.  I felt like I bought a product that was still early in its beta.  The worst part of it all is I work minimum wage at a grocery store and I feel like I threw all my hours there out the window.  I kind of want to save up for the 21ux but I am going to feel quite stupid having two.  I was better off with my intuos 3 and my 1920x1200 laptop display.

Anyways to make the most of what I have, and hopefully make it worth the money some time...

Rtil, what settings to you use for the monitor, for example brightness, contrast and color settings?  The factory preset is truly awful.  Also, do you have the same problem as me when it comes to poor calibration?

ansel

Quote from: shittyfurryass
Quote from: rtilsee folks this is why if you want a cintiq you should just save up for the 21ux it makes the 12wx look more like a piece of crap than it already is

This post came a month too late

I bought myself a 12wx for my birthday and boy am I disappointed.  My EEE pc that cost me $180 new has a better looking display, and my cellphone calibrates better than it.  Why does my phone test calibration at 5 points while my cintiq tests at only two?! This makes working with a god awfully low resolution even more annoying when you cant make the most out of the edges of the screen. I am hoping a driver update will fix this.  Not to mention the tablet is small, but shares the same trade offs as having a big one in terms of portability since the thing is a frigging octopus.  I felt like I bought a product that was still early in its beta.  The worst part of it all is I work minimum wage at a grocery store and I feel like I threw all my hours there out the window.  I kind of want to save up for the 21ux but I am going to feel quite stupid having two.  I was better off with my intuos 3 and my 1920x1200 laptop display.

Anyways to make the most of what I have, and hopefully make it worth the money some time...

Rtil, what settings to you use for the monitor, for example brightness, contrast and color settings?  The factory preset is truly awful.  Also, do you have the same problem as me when it comes to poor calibration?

Wow. sounds like the 12wx is basically a huge waste of money in all respects. Sorry to hear that story, spending that kind of money on something that turned out to actually be detrimental to your work sounds incredibly frustrating. You can probably sell it used through craigslist/something similar to get back at least some of your money, and just from my experience today the 21UX is really worth the price--it's an excellent monitor and an excellent tablet. However, if you're working minimum-wage and already have an intuos and a nice display, don't starve yourself to buy it. aahsghdghgdshdfd

Quote from: Factoryshut up you skinny white ugly prick

shittyfurryass

it probably isn't too terrible, it is just that i set my expectations high since it is a wacom tablet and close to $1000 and that set me into a bitch fest.  Especially since I bought my eee pc at the same time, and I have been neglecting something that is $1000 for something that is $200.  The grass is probably always greener on the other side, and if I did not buy it, I would still be longing for one, and I would have probably wished I bought the smaller one if I got the 21ux.  I am glad you posted this though, since I will consider it once I have a real job, but for now I am not going to bother selling what I just bought and make the best of it.

rtil

Quote from: shittyfurryass
Quote from: rtilsee folks this is why if you want a cintiq you should just save up for the 21ux it makes the 12wx look more like a piece of crap than it already is

This post came a month too late

I bought myself a 12wx for my birthday and boy am I disappointed.  My EEE pc that cost me $180 new has a better looking display, and my cellphone calibrates better than it.  Why does my phone test calibration at 5 points while my cintiq tests at only two?! This makes working with a god awfully low resolution even more annoying when you cant make the most out of the edges of the screen. I am hoping a driver update will fix this.  Not to mention the tablet is small, but shares the same trade offs as having a big one in terms of portability since the thing is a frigging octopus.  I felt like I bought a product that was still early in its beta.  The worst part of it all is I work minimum wage at a grocery store and I feel like I threw all my hours there out the window.  I kind of want to save up for the 21ux but I am going to feel quite stupid having two.  I was better off with my intuos 3 and my 1920x1200 laptop display.

Anyways to make the most of what I have, and hopefully make it worth the money some time...

Rtil, what settings to you use for the monitor, for example brightness, contrast and color settings?  The factory preset is truly awful.  Also, do you have the same problem as me when it comes to poor calibration?
sorry, i've spoken ill about the 12WX before but obviously you haven't seen it. it was way back in the flash help section. trust me, i've been hoping for a driver update for a long time. they could fix the crappy calibration issue (and probably the stupid drawing problem as well) easily.

the settings i have are:
brightness: 58
contrast: 46
backlight: 50

color: direct 255 everything

but it still kind of looks like garbage. this was the closest i could get it to the correct gamma, unfortunately. i might tinker with it again, but i honestly haven't even turned the thing on in over a month.

jjjjjjjjjj

Quote from: HarryTheHeadJust getting used to not being able to rotate my intuos was a big step, a good one when adjusting to sketching on larger areas, but I could never stand drawing in the same positions as I paint.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YEt1BuYaoZo


ansel

Quote from: Zekeyi love my tabletpc

A POX ON THEE



Quote from: Factoryshut up you skinny white ugly prick

lenko

I love my mouse, still can't get used to tablets
<emanhattan> i remember pingu ice cream
<emanhattan> it was a better time
<emanhattan> when the penguins were cold and delicious
<emanhattan> and i knew i was gonna be
<emanhattan> consequence free

creamcorn

ok im convinced ill stick with my bamboo fun medium

creamcorn

by the way congratulations with your cintiqits really nice and cool


|