id like some critique.

Started by unclephil, March 1, 2009 03:54 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

squffin

Ya instead of being a fucking prick why don't you get a real artiste's book and be a man, get the jenny out ya spine. Protect ya god damn neck this aint no fuckin game son this is your life this is your god damned life.


rtil

#22
it's a decent test i guess
you have a line consistency problem and your character's teeth go from a few giant ones to a little strip at the top
i think you should focus less on stunted, short "wacky" tests and actually practice some fundamentals of animation

Loathsome

you really don't need a book to learn
but i'm not going to deny it's a good book
i have it myself


ZekeySpaceyLizard

Quote from: Loathsomeyou really don't need a book to learn
but i'm not going to deny it's a good book
i have it myself


rtil

you don't need a book but if the only other outlet you have is the internet


well


you need the book

f0d

Quote from: rtilyou have a line consistency problem and your character's teeth go from a few giant ones to a little strip at the top
teeth? i thought that was his tongue and he was saying "la"

either way its not a realistic mouth movement

and you dont need the survival guide or the internet to become an animator, but you'll probably suck ass if you dont unless you're a freak (it happens... some of the self taught animators in the film school are mind blowing)

I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

unclephil

i have the book. ive never found time to read it though. hopefully over summer.

f0d

im a little over halfway done.. the walk cycle stuff is immensely interesting

hopefully ill find time to finish it over spring break
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

DrRumack

i read the whole thing in two nights
ima speed reader

<Naza> i hate penis exect mine
<Tyler Naugle> JOKE  TIME w/ JOKEOB BRECK
<+pantsman> you have yet to show me any applicable sign of intelligence yet scrib...
<HatsuneMiku> the pings and timeouts of jacob breck
<dilly> the tba will look up and cry "save us!".... and i'll look down and whisper .... "h"
Quote from: stealth trollwhat's up with you not sucking dicks like the faggot you are
<+fluffkomix> mrscriblam has added you as a friend
<+fluffkomix> ignore

<+mrscriblam> lmao

creamcorn

i just ordered the book
does it make any references to any classic animations/cartoons? and if they do, what are they i want to see them before i read the book cos i dont want to go back and forth all the time

Gerkinman

Ive been using the book a fair bit lately, mainly going back to the walk cycles, i love that part of the book.

texas

i was going to read the survival guide but the first thing it said was to learn how to draw first so i stopped
or am i imagining that it said that

f0d

Quote from: chickeni just ordered the book
does it make any references to any classic animations/cartoons? and if they do, what are they i want to see them before i read the book cos i dont want to go back and forth all the time

there are very few references to famous or classic animations except at the beginning of the book. and the book is so well illustrated you'll never have any trouble figuring out what its talking about. you dont really need any prior knowledge going in

Quote from: The Last Gunslingeri was going to read the survival guide but the first thing it said was to learn how to draw first so i stopped
or am i imagining that it said that
yeah it says that you have to learn to draw to be a succesful animator, and in my opinion its right whether you like what it says or not.

weight is fundamental to animation and youll have a hard time with weight if you havent done some anatomy or life drawing
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

GadZooks1357

Quote from: The Last Gunslingeri was going to read the survival guide but the first thing it said was to learn how to draw first so i stopped
or am i imagining that it said that
I don't remember it actually saying that, but regardless, it isn't a how-to-draw book; it's a how-to-animate book.

A lot of the exercises, like walk or run cycles and jumping, are doable with crude drawings, like stick figures, so if you want to get the basics of animation down, you can do a hell of a lot worse than using the survival guide.

But as someone said, it gets more complicated as it goes on, such as using squash/stretch techniques, implying weight, and accents where you need somewhat more detailed drawings to practice them.

rtil

as long as you can draw a bean with arms, legs and a head you should be good to go for the entire book

emanhattan

I like the example of the gay man he gives on the walk cycle part of the book