why does cs4 suck so much dick

Started by f0d, February 19, 2009 01:21 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

f0d

i spent all night monday helping out my classmates with their flash projects which were due the next day... like literally 8 hours troubleshooting. virtually everyone encountered problems, and i would say 95% of the problems were due to them trying to use the new features in CS4

first off, the bone tool. absolute most worthless piece of shit tool they could have possibly added. its not only a pointless shortcut to a technique that can be achieved much more convincingly with normal symbols, tweens, and easing, its also just horribly designed. the anchor point for the bone tool is FIXED. you cant MOVE IT. therefore, its useless on the main timeline. the only way ive discovered that you can actually move a graphic or vector connected to an armature is by making it into a new symbol, then moving the symbol. otherwise, you can try moving it, but you'll just move the joints around while the anchor stays in place. why not just make it so the anchor moves when you click on it? in addition, when part of an armature overlaps with another part of an armature, it inverts and looks god awful. i think this is only when you use the bone tool on vectors though.

second, tweens. why on gods green earth did they decide that classic tweens were too complicated? what shithead at adobe decided that they had to design their new tweens for retarded people who can't grasp the concept of one keyframe to another? they've dumbed it down so much its actually now harder to use. i wanted to make a perfect loop using the new type of motion tween, but it was impossible to remove the last frame of the tween and have it smoothly loop back to the beginning... every time you click on it, it selects the whole goddamned tween on the timeline, instead of just the keyframe you want to select. and while the new motion path thing is a decent concept, its so poorly executed. i was trying to edit a motion path using the subselection tool and it had like 20 different little hitches that you had to move one by one. its also really hard to edit the motion path because it basically doesn't exist on the timeline or anywhere unless the tween is selected. this makes it so you can't hide the symbol while you edit its path, and you'll select the synbol when trying to select the path. all it does is replace what a guide layer could already do, anyways.

third, the layout... it blows dick, and i cant for the life of me get it to look anything even remotely like cs3 or flash 8. sure theres more space to draw, but i dont give a fuck about that. i want quick access to all of the features. and when it takes me ten minutes just to find where the fuckin color mixer is, there is a problem. then again i was using it on a mac, and dockable windows are a lot less useful when you can see right past them to the desktop. every time i tried to put the toolbar or library in its proper places id end up minimizing flash by accident, which made me want to break things

and fourth, WHY THE RELIANCE ON AS3? the bone tool and new tweens don't rely on AS3 to work because they're easily converted to FBF, but the 3D objects and 3D tweens do. WHY!? AS3 is for coders. no one else can figure the shit out. they need to either make AS2 work with everything or make AS3 easier to use. NOW.



so can anyone enlighten me as to the supposed advantages of all this stupid retarded new shit? because i honest to god think cs4 is the worst new edition of flash yet. in an attempt to make things less complicated, adobe has made everything woefully MORE complicated.

i still think as far as improving the program from one edition to another, flash 8 is hands down the best version yet
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

rtil

#1
first off i moved this topic because you posted it in introductions for some reason

anyway i agree with you on a lot of points. i think adobe rushed out the cs4 line, especially flash as not only do a lot of the features feel incomplete but it's also rather unstable. the only thing it trumps cs3 in is memory management and importing/exporting video.

the bones tool is probably the worst new feature. it's not well developed. IK is a pretty simple thing to do, even in 3d. but in flash it's very easy to fuck up the rig and most often you'll go back through your animation after spending painstaking hours putting it together only to find out you somehow made a symbol invert and stretch itself 4 miles across the stage halfway through.

because of this i often convert all my IK animation to frame by frame animation as soon as possible.

i was able to move the entire rig around though so i'm not sure what happened there but that does sound frustrating

the new tweens are also very strange to me. they seem too complicated for simple tasks. i hardly ever use them. the one thing they are good for though is arced movement, something that used to only be accomplished with motion paths can now be easily tweaked with a visible, editable arc. you can also ease individual properties of the symbol which is nice as well. still though, i find classic tweens to be of more use to me compared to the new ones.

the layout is fine to me, although i find a lot of the toolbars to be bloated. on my old monitor they would take up almost the entire screen. now i have a 23" widescreen so it's better, but they still are a little on the large side.

as far as best version of flash, i'm going to have to say cs3. stable, solid, some extra features that i wished 8 had as well.

cs4 feels like the windows ME of adobe packages. it's a transitional stage and it's not very solid.. but it has some good ideas for the next generation.

f0d

Quote from: rtilfirst off i moved this topic because you posted it in introductions for some reason
lmfao it just appeared there, i made the topic in flash help... at least i thought i did

Quote from: rtilas far as best version of flash, i'm going to have to say cs3. stable, solid, some extra features that i wished 8 had as well.

cs4 feels like the windows ME of adobe packages. it's a transitional stage and it's not very solid.. but it has some good ideas for the next generation.

cs3 would be better than 8 if it werent for AS3

and i agree they can build on these new features and make them good. its just a matter of making them intuitive instead of bewildering
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

rtil

as3 makes sense from a programming standpoint but to animators it's just annoying to have to re-learn how to do simple things

and it does require more code to do them

jjjjjjjjjj

cs4 is the only version of flash to ever crash on me.
with cs4 its like im relearning flash again

ZekeySpaceyLizard

i cant wait til the day one of adobe's competitors puts them out of business

its gonna happen sooner or later

emanhattan

I had to use cs4 once it was horrible.


ansel

f0d I agree with everything you said. I think all the tools in cs4 are good ideas, but are just incredibly poorly executed-- the bone tool in particular is vastly disappointing. Hoping CS5 refines these things and gets rid of the horrible, horrible tweens.

you may find this amusing

Quote from: Factoryshut up you skinny white ugly prick

Kött

I couldn't even be bothered to try to learn Flash CS4 until I wanted to try some 3d animation... but the new, so called "3d elements" or the "z-axis" is even more useless than anything else the entire program delivered! I didn't even make it to create a goddamn rotating box that looks semi professional.
What is a 3d function good for if the z axis doesn't even affect the depth/arrangement of the single objects, placed on the same layer?
:3

squffin

looks like adobe dawgs took a big shit in a program and sold it for thousands of dollars lOL dawg............

mishkamash

[size=]HOLY SHIT MY DOCUMENT IS HOVERING OFF THE FUCKING WINDOW[/size]
<lenko> i saw a hedgehog on the way home if i was drunk i would have yelled IM DOCTOR RRRRROBOTNIK and chased it 

f0d

Quote from: MishkaMash[size=]HOLY SHIT MY DOCUMENT IS HOVERING OFF THE FUCKING WINDOW[/size]
i HATE that shit.
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

billy

Quote from: rtilas3 makes sense from a programming standpoint but to animators it's just annoying to have to re-learn how to do simple things

and it does require more code to do them

it's not like you can't just change as version to whatever you're used to

rtil

#13
Quote from: Billy
Quote from: rtilas3 makes sense from a programming standpoint but to animators it's just annoying to have to re-learn how to do simple things

and it does require more code to do them

it's not like you can't just change as version to whatever you're used to
you can't if you're using some of cs4's new features

f0d

Quote from: rtil
Quote from: Billy
Quote from: rtilas3 makes sense from a programming standpoint but to animators it's just annoying to have to re-learn how to do simple things

and it does require more code to do them

it's not like you can't just change as version to whatever you're used to
you can't if you're using some of cs4's new features
yep none of the 3D shit works, bone tool goes all out of whack, tweens are converted to FBF, etc. all just from switching to actionscript 2.0. i mean it gave me an error message just trying to change it to AS2 on the publish settings. plus it took me an hour to find the code to make a button go to the next scene. and then another hour to figure out the hilariously stupid fact that you add the code to the main timeline and not the symbol itself

cs3 allowed AS3 to be easily turned off with no consequences, adobe are just a bunch of retards for forcing it to be the standard in cs4
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

rtil

well at some point it's going to need to be implemented. in all fairness programming languages must evolve over time to accomodate the needs of developers. i'm sure AS1 people were sad when AS2 brought on a lot of changes, but a lot of those changes ended up being good and produced great software with it like 8 and cs3.

the best we can hope for is a stable version in cs5

f0d

oooh what about AS4 for non coders?
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

rtil


f0d

meaning what if they made AS4 more animator and graphic designer friendly
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

Mightydein

I somehow predicted that these new versions of flash were gonna be terrible right when flash 8 came out.

By the way if you want to be using older versions of flash i found this site where they have all the past trail versions available there fully functional too.

It's where i dug up FlashMX2004 for myself.

http://flash-ascript.blogspot.com/2007/06/...turesplash.html