The Frame Limit....

Started by YungJazz, September 14, 2008 08:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

YungJazz

I always heard that the frame limit for Flash was 16,000. But is that just for MX and 8? I spent a few minutes playing around in CS3 and found that the limit was 32,000ish. This excited me, because I would love to make a 20-minute flash at my normal 24 fps, do frames on different layers or inside symbols/buttons affect the limit or just the ones numbered on the main timeline?


I warned you, stupid.

psi43

just animate in a movieclip, that fixes the problem

rtil

Quote from: Oliver Reipschlägerjust animate in a movieclip, that fixes the problem
this

technically, if you animate your movie this way , @ 24 fps you could fit 71,111 minutes of footage in your swf. technically speaking of course.

Ying

Quote from: rtil
Quote from: Oliver Reipschlägerjust animate in a movieclip, that fixes the problem
this

technically, if you animate your movie this way , @ 24 fps you could fit 71,111 minutes of footage in your swf. technically speaking of course.

a movie that would take 49 days to watch

FrozenSheep

I heard somewhere that there is an export frame limit.

adamant

Quote from: rtil
Quote from: Oliver Reipschlägerjust animate in a movieclip, that fixes the problem
this

technically, if you animate your movie this way , @ 24 fps you could fit 71,111 minutes of footage in your swf. technically speaking of course.

what about plugging more movie clips inside of that one movie clip?

rtil

Quote from: unconditionallyguarANTeed
Quote from: rtil
Quote from: Oliver Reipschlägerjust animate in a movieclip, that fixes the problem
this

technically, if you animate your movie this way , @ 24 fps you could fit 71,111 minutes of footage in your swf. technically speaking of course.

what about plugging more movie clips inside of that one movie clip?
LMAO
then you'd have
oh god
(((32000/24)/60)*32000)^32000² minutes of footage
or something
and that's just assuming  you're putting one movie clip on every frame inside a movie clip on every frame on the root timeline
so technically speaking the number of frames you can have in flash is infinite
the end!

LordZeebmork

^ I think there\\\'s a movie clip limit.

http://www.kirupa.com/forum/archive/index.php/t-16877.html although this is old as fuck and I have broken some of those so it can\\\'t be 100% right.

I read about it somewhere else but I can\\\'t find the page.

the longest you could get is if you didn\\\'t use any movie clips until the 15999th frame, where you stopped the root timeline and let the movie clip play, then you put a movie clip in there and didn\\\'t use any movie clips in that until the 15999th frame, stopped it there, and let the movie clip play, and so on for 16000 movie clips.

I think that means you can have 177777.777083333333... minutes of animation in a flash at 24fps maximum, but I got three hours of sleep so it\\\'s probably wrong.

and then you have scenes but nobody uses those anyway and I\\\'m not sure how they would affect the result

also http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic/505025/1
let's all set our phasers on "boring"

YungJazz

That's wassup. So I don't have anything to worry about then.


I warned you, stupid.

rtil

Quote from: LordZeebmork^ I think there's a movie clip limit.

http://www.kirupa.com/forum/archive/index.php/t-16877.html although this is old as fuck and I have broken some of those so it can't be 100% right.

I read about it somewhere else but I can't find the page.

the longest you could get is if you didn't use any movie clips until the 15999th frame, where you stopped the root timeline and let the movie clip play, then you put a movie clip in there and didn't use any movie clips in that until the 15999th frame, stopped it there, and let the movie clip play, and so on for 16000 movie clips.

I think that means you can have 177777.777083333333... minutes of animation in a flash at 24fps maximum, but I got three hours of sleep so it's probably wrong.

and then you have scenes but nobody uses those anyway and I'm not sure how they would affect the result

also http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic/505025/1
the people on that bbs page are retarded and can't do math to save their lives

anyway, if there is a movie clip/library limit, i'd imagine it would be somehow related to the limits of the machine you're working on rather than a cap in the software.

LordZeebmork

Quote from: rtilthe people on that bbs page are retarded and can't do math to save their lives

yeah, well, what do you expect from newgrounds?

the only reason I linked to it was for the thing about the 16000 mc limit which I think exists

too bad there's no way to test it other than creating 16000 mcs which would take an incredibly long time

Quoteanyway, if there is a movie clip/library limit, i'd imagine it would be somehow related to the limits of the machine you're working on rather than a cap in the software.
hmm, I thought there was a 16000 limit for most things

I once reached the limit of how big you can set the size of a mc through the properties thing (incoherent rambling thffff) although it was possible to make it larger with the stretch/whatever tool

I think it was 7880 or something like that, not sure though, and I can't be bothered to open flash to check
let's all set our phasers on "boring"

rtil

16,000 library asset limit

well

sounds reasonable
the most i've ever had wasn't more than a thousand

YungJazz

well even if there was a limit inside a mc, i doubt i'd be putting a whole 5-10 minute flash inside one, i like using scenes as long as a background song has ended


I warned you, stupid.

sQueef

Quote(good luck otherwise... will want to see what happens when one gets blammed or people scream at you when they say "OGM! ONLY 300kb BUT IT HAD TO DOWNLOAD 16,000 5MB MOVIES!!!!!111). So your call here.

for real dog i want to make a movie that loads immense amounts of data but seems to fit in the newgrounds upload limit that would truly bring me pleasure

what exactly could you accomplish by forcing weak computers to try and process such amounts of data?
if its not as evil and such as im imagining than forget it
Oh, wretched ephemeral race ... why do you compel me to tell you what it would be most expedient for you not to hear? What is best of all is utterly beyond your reach: not to be born, not to be, to be nothing. But the second best for you is—to die soon.

LordZeebmork

Quote from: Squeef
Quote(good luck otherwise... will want to see what happens when one gets blammed or people scream at you when they say "OGM! ONLY 300kb BUT IT HAD TO DOWNLOAD 16,000 5MB MOVIES!!!!!111). So your call here.

for real dog i want to make a movie that loads immense amounts of data but seems to fit in the newgrounds upload limit that would truly bring me pleasure

what exactly could you accomplish by forcing weak computers to try and process such amounts of data?
if its not as evil and such as im imagining than forget it
hmm

well

it would take forever to load

and you might be able to eat a fuckton of memory but I'm not really sure

there are easier ways to completely fuck over a computer

hell, I made a swf that filter-rapes computers to death
let's all set our phasers on "boring"


sQueef

i remember when i was a wee lad and using the 30day trial of flash
and

every frame i made in a different scene and i was like "how the hell do people keep their bg's and stuff so consistent redrawing it in every frame without anything to go off of???"
Oh, wretched ephemeral race ... why do you compel me to tell you what it would be most expedient for you not to hear? What is best of all is utterly beyond your reach: not to be born, not to be, to be nothing. But the second best for you is—to die soon.

LordZeebmork

I never learned how to use scenes
let's all set our phasers on "boring"

mishkamash

Quote from: LordZeebmorkI never learned how to use scenes
<lenko> i saw a hedgehog on the way home if i was drunk i would have yelled IM DOCTOR RRRRROBOTNIK and chased it 

adamant

Quote from: Squeefevery frame i made in a different scene and i was like "how the hell do people keep their bg's and stuff so consistent redrawing it in every frame without anything to go off of???"

lmao gertie the dinosaur