MASSSSSSSS VOTEEEEEEEEEEEE

Started by Philip K Dick, March 30, 2008 05:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

|

MRat

Quote from: CoolDrMoney
QuoteMike even admits he felt dirty reusing backgrounds and symbols. I think he agrees with alot of what we have to say about the technical aspects of his series, which, as far as I'm concerned is what matters.

Well he certainly seemd mad when I pointed it out to him!


That's why I brought it up, and he felt like he overreacted. Or so he claims.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

rtil

#141
he always does that. he's like a senile dog. they bite you when you get anywhere near them and then feel all sorry for it a few seconds later

MRat

Quote from: rtilhe always does that. he's like a senile dog. they bite you when you get anywhere near them and then feel all sorry for it a few seconds later


alot of people are like this. I don't hate him for it.


Sure I don't think he's that funny, but he's never done anything, that I've personally witnessed at least, that I would all out condemn. And when I talk to him, he's a really nice guy.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

sQueef

I think the swain has a lot of talent his drawings are pretty sound, and he's got a better mastery of Flash than I do.

But I might be easily impressed so yeah. I can honestly say with no personal arrogance that I only laughed at one part during Mastermind 3, but I'm sure a lot of people loved it so why not let them have their fun.

It wasn't my sense of humor that's all, im a weird person though I'm sure so it's no big deal. I don't want to be like everyone else and I don't want everyone to be like me so wait whAT THE FUC AM I TALKING ABOUT SHUT UP
Oh, wretched ephemeral race ... why do you compel me to tell you what it would be most expedient for you not to hear? What is best of all is utterly beyond your reach: not to be born, not to be, to be nothing. But the second best for you is—to die soon.

W.A.C.

Quote from: MRatHey I reviewed Mastermind 3 with a 9. I didn't mind it at all. But would I say it was good? Nah.
If you don't consider it good, why did you give it a 9?

MRat

Quote from: W.A.C.
Quote from: MRatHey I reviewed Mastermind 3 with a 9. I didn't mind it at all. But would I say it was good? Nah.
If you don't consider it good, why did you give it a 9?


Because it wasn't bad?


Here's I write reviews. Just meh is a 5. Bad is below 5, and you can climb up points but doing thigns I like. I like his colour palette, I like the mastermind as a character, and i like the music choices. That was enough to get a 9 from me, because there were no factors the really brought it down.



I don't count content in my score, because that's just taste and doesnt really include technical skill at all. I do include HOW you show off that content though. I rate a 10 second submission like it was an hour long and an hour long submission like it was 10 seconds. If you fill the time the properly, length doesn't matter at all.


So many factors are influences, but I try to let content not be one of them. That's why even though I didn't think Mastermind was good, I can appreciate other aspects.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

rtil

because anything lower is abusive and will get deleted

MRat

Quote from: rtilbecause anything lower is abusive and will get deleted


this too, very much this too.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

W.A.C.

I'm a much harsher reviewer. >_> [LINK]

MRat

Quote from: W.A.C.I'm a much harsher reviewer. >_> [LINK]


I've read all that, and I really hate it honestly. Mostly just when it comes down to story though.


You're sense of story is so narrow and flawed. I got started in art through literature, and there is no such thing as a "well structured story" only a well told one. Structure is relative to how the author is going to tell it, and there isn't a way to say it was right, only to say if it does what it's intending to do.


For example, the movie Natural Born Killers by Oliver Stone. It's structure was a mess. There was no rhyme nor reason to the flash backs mixed with the modern happenings mixed with the solutions. I was almost impossible to tell what was the story and what was support of it. However, that movie is one of the greatest movies of all time because IT CONVEYS EXACTLY WHAT THE DIRECTOR WANTS IT TO IN THE WAY THE DIRECTOR WANTS. That's why movies like Step Up aren't good. Because they're about inner city kids and urban dancing, and they have these dramatic emotional stories, but the filmmaker turns it into a second rate music video where all the characters spout cliches, and you have this tale vying for your attention and emotional response, but all you get is a gag because some tiny white kid is super gangsta.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

f0d

i completely agree mrat

no country for old men is kinda like that. it doesnt follow the usual three act structure of conflict, climax, resolution, etc because its based on a work of literature that doesn't conform to movie script guidelines. many conflicts in that movie end up left entirely unresolved. my friends all fuckin hated it because of the ending, but i loved it personally.
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

MRat

Quote from: f0di completely agree mrat

no country for old men is kinda like that. it doesnt follow the usual three act structure of conflict, climax, resolution, etc because its based on a work of literature that doesn't conform to movie script guidelines. many conflicts in that movie end up left entirely unresolved. my friends all fuckin hated it because of the ending, but i loved it personally.


Yep. While I thought There Will Be Blood was still better myself, it was a close run, and there were alot of layers to No Country that never would have been there if it was told conventionally or with "structure"


For example SPOILERSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS[size="6"][/size][color="#8B0000"][/color]

When Brolin's character dies, to me, is a crowning moment in modern cinema. The way they treated that was brilliant, and really captured so many elements important to the theme, as well as the pace, which in it of itself, was different.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

ZekeySpaceyLizard

There Will Be Blood was the Sideways of this year's Oscars.

Should have won.
But didnt.

Although I love all the Coen's films

MRat

Not to mention things like Robot Frogs are supposed to be pointless and simply make you go "What?"


If it did that, THEN YOU SHOULD BE GIVING IT A FUCKING !O, because it succeeded in doing what it was supposed to do.

This is like saying Clerk 2 is terrible because you don't like donkeys and there's a donkey in it.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

billy

I use IGN's 7-9 rating scale.

7 = shit
8 = good
9 = mind blowing

f0d

Quote from: MRatYep. While I thought There Will Be Blood was still better myself, it was a close run, and there were alot of layers to No Country that never would have been there if it was told conventionally or with "structure"
still need to see there will be blood it looked phenomenal






DONT READ IF YOU HAVENT SEEN THE MOVIE YET

Quote from: MRatWhen Brolin's character dies, to me, is a crowning moment in modern cinema. The way they treated that was brilliant, and really captured so many elements important to the theme, as well as the pace, which in it of itself, was different.

oh yea that scene was crazy. the coens only allow you to imagine what goes on in the 10 seconds before tommy lee jones arrives on the scene based on the carnage he sees afterwards. i can see why some people would've been confused or dissatisfied with that part, i know i didnt get it the first time. at first i thought he cheated on his wife with that woman by the pool for some reason. after watching it a second time and understanding it, that was definitely one of the best scenes in the movie. same with the scene where antone is waiting in the hotel room, then isnt there when tommy lee jones breaks in. when i first saw that i was like "what the fUCK" but i think i understand it now

the differences between the novel and the movie were actually pretty significant at those parts. the coens were otherwise faithful to the text, from what my friend tells me.
I have more of a life writing this review at 1145 pm than you guys do making these movies. . .

MRat

The Coens did a good job of remaining pretty faithful yeah.

I was one of those few guys who wasn't confused in the movie, and got pissed when people outside were talking about how confusing it was.
I was gone, FOR SO LONG

ZekeySpaceyLizard

if people found No Country confusing, I hope they dont ever see The Prestige or Memento

their minds would explode

MindChamber

Quote from: Zekeyif people found No Country confusing, I hope they dont ever see The Prestige or Memento

their minds would explode


I thought prestige was pretty formula,  memento was cool but a bit gimmicky.

No country was da shit,  mostly because of the insane and intense acting. I liked the ending because it reflected closer to real life than most movies.

psi43

^Yeah but dicks, vaginas and tits aren't funny. I am not saying that I disliked Masterminds 3, it's ok. It's by far better than the other masterminds but still.

|