why do all the good animations on NG get a super high score nowadays?

Started by psi43, October 26, 2007 12:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

psi43

It's kind of weird. When Adam Phillips submitted his stuff 2 years ago he got like 4.11 for it and that was super high #1 for sure. Now Eddsworld's flash has a score of 4.30 and it's not even close to the art/animation level of AP's shit.

It's really weird that a lot of things get super high scores nowadays.

rtil

what baffles me is that everything has a 9.8 in review score now


W.A.C.

Quote from: rtilwhat baffles me is that everything has a 9.8 in review score now

That's mostly because M-Bot deletes negative reviews if people don't spend a ridiculous amount of time making them where with positive reviews, it can be one sentence and considered exceptable. Stupid strict review policies.

Necronomitr0n

It is impossible to leave any type of critique, constructive or abusive, on NG.
<+fawx> im trying to animate a dick coming out of a toaster how do i go on about doing this
<~rtil> well fawx what you would do is delete the fla and do something productive instead

<+ansel> i lure children into my van with candy and then i read them passages from 'the origin of species'
<%ropesnake> billy con ends with billy raping his cat
<+billymonks> FUCK YOU BUG

<~rtil> ya one time i gave this hobo some cat food and he ate it like the animal he is it pleased me

psi43

# Awesome Compilation Vol 4, by EgoraptorCatch-Me said: "best so far"
# Bowser\\\'s Kingdom: Eps 6, by araskin500Deathgag101 said: "HISTERICAL"
# Bowser\\\'s Kingdom: Eps 666, by araskin500latin78 said: "really good!"
# Bowser\\\'s Kingdom: Eps 4, by araskin500supernajio100 said: "LOL"
# Bowser\\\'s Kingdom: Eps 5, by araskin500TheMadDogofDarkness said: "omg so awesome!!!!"



AWESOME

weekly top5

ghostinglostfan

i want to go to newgrounds and review everything with this review:



Sinitron

Quote from: SystekIt is impossible to leave any type of critique, constructive or abusive, on NG.

ahahahaha you suck



Summary: "Crudely made and generally lame."

Random bitmaps, poor shape tweens, filters, etc... I could go on, but there really is no point; The graphics are terrible and that\\\'s that. While most of you seem to have a grasp of the various effects and whatever that Flash has to offer, none of you have any skill whatsoever when it comes down to pure illustration. Look up some tutorials, or practise more, whatever floats your boat.

Sound was okay at times, but nothing really outstanding, and often annoying. Try something that goes better with the actual on-screen action... After improving said action, of course.

The best part was probably the menu, however this could have been expanded and improved upon to a point where it smoothly faded in and out when switching back and forth between the various sets of authors.

Not really super for a Super Collab.
Review Score: 1 / 10


Summary: "This was, in my opinion, rather lame."

While there were some mediocre graphics, the rest was lacking. The audio quality was too low, the animation was too cheap, and most important of all the JOKES were terrible. I think you should try to either use more detailed graphics, or spend more time on the actual animation. You should also reconsider your use of "cock jokes", and get proper audio, or atleast sharper audio to make it easier for viewers to understand the dialogue. Try again, and try harder. With some more effort put in I\\\'m sure you can do it.
Review Score: 2 / 10


Summary: "Not very impressive."

The visual style was not coherent at all (and it didn\\\'t seem like you tried to make it fit together, either), and the animation was sub-par. The audio quality was decent, not too good but not bad either, however I can not say that I am a fan of the tune you chose. I am sure you could have dug up something better for a theme song, or maybe even made something unique for yourself. You obviously seem to know how to handle Swift3D, but you didn\\\'t really put it to good use, and you didn\\\'t really show your skills through this submission. Please, try to work harder with your visuals, and keep the style fluid rather than jumpy; Mixing 2D sprites with a 3D logo really isn\\\'t the greatest of ideas.
Review Score: 2 / 10


^ these all have like 2 people agreeing and 20-50 calling bullshit y0w


adamant

Quote from: SystekIt is impossible to leave any type of critique, constructive or abusive, on NG.

It is pointless to leave any type of critique on NG because they never listen anyway.  

Sinitron

Quote from: unconditionallyguarANTeed
Quote from: SystekIt is impossible to leave any type of critique, constructive or abusive, on NG.

It is pointless to leave any type of critique on NG because they never listen anyway.  

this is more accurate

not blaming the people on the recieving end though most NG users are almost as retarded as you guys

rtil

people usually don't act like they're listening because the critic is either right and/or they're too attached to their work . art is a unique type of work where the creator is more harsh to criticism to it because it's their "baby", much like a mother would be upset if someone else criticized their parental behaviors or their child

KingDavid

Quote from: taylor
Quote from: Sinitronit sucks ass okay

and muse isnt that great anyway
thanks ill use this comment to help myself improve

Sinitron

Quote from: rtilpeople usually don't act like they're listening because the critic is either right and/or they're too attached to their work . art is a unique type of work where the creator is more harsh to criticism to it because it's their "baby", much like a mother would be upset if someone else criticized their parental behaviors or their child

i dont listen because i already know that it sucks loL

anigen

Quote from: Psi43# Awesome Compilation Vol 4, by EgoraptorCatch-Me said: "best so far"

oh god is that a real ng user


rtil

a couple hundred more and they'll catch on to your game


trent bortknob

i like how most of the responses if there are any are just "Thank you."